When Toronto Maple Leafs general manager Brad Treliving signed Simon Benoit, he intended him as blue-line insurance. Despite initial skepticism and questions about allocating valuable salary-cap space to a player with a lackluster season with the Anaheim Ducks, Benoit found his way into the team due to injuries.
Critics wondered why invest in a player who struggled in Anaheim, managing only three goals and seven assists in 78 games with a concerning minus-29 plus/minus rating. Maple Leafs fans expressed frustration, fearing that Coach Sheldon Keefe might favor Benoit over more skilled defensemen. Some labeled him a “Bust,” casting doubt on his potential contributions, while others sarcastically suggested planning a parade for his signing.
However, as the Maple Leafs training camp unfolded, a different narrative emerged. In a late September article, Luke Fox highlighted Benoit’s confidence and resilience. Despite coming from a team labeled as “terrible,” Benoit approached the camp with a never-quit mentality, determined to earn a spot on the roster.
This unwavering attitude seems to have paid off, as Benoit, over 33 games, has secured a surprising role on the Maple Leafs’ second pairing alongside Jake McCabe. His journey from a questionable signing to an integral part of the team challenges initial doubts and underscores the value of perseverance in the unpredictable world of professional hockey.