Steelers’ Punter Woes: Could Matt Araiza Be the Solution?

In a recent move, the Steelers made some notable cuts on Monday, one of which saw punter Pressley Harvin III being released. This departure has ignited discussions, with former All-Pro punter Pat McAfee suggesting that Pittsburgh should consider signing Matt Araiza during the offseason.

McAfee emphasized Araiza’s potential suitability for the AFC North stadiums, highlighting the necessity for a strong leg in such environments. He also pointed out Araiza’s nickname, the ‘Punt God,’ underscoring the talent and potential he brings to the table. McAfee further alluded to Araiza’s tumultuous journey, noting his exoneration from charges and subsequent absence from the NFL scene, making the Steelers a possible landing spot for his return.

Araiza’s NFL journey began when he was drafted by the Buffalo Bills in the sixth round of the 2022 NFL Draft. However, his promising start was marred by accusations of sexual assault at an off-campus party in 2021, leading to his release from the team shortly after. Despite vehemently denying the allegations, Araiza faced a challenging legal battle until December 2023 when the charges were dropped by the accuser, and Araiza dismissed his defamation countersuit against her.

Despite being cleared of charges, Araiza has yet to attract interest from NFL teams, leaving his football future uncertain. However, his collegiate achievements speak volumes, as he set NCAA records in punt average, 60-yard punts, 50-yard punts, and 70-yard punts during his time at college. Notably, he showcased his talent with an 82-yard punt for the Bills during the 2022 preseason.

For the Steelers, Araiza represents a potential upgrade over their recent punting performances. Harvin III’s average of 43.7 yards per punt over the past three years fell short of expectations, prompting the team to seek alternatives. With Araiza’s proven track record and potential to excel in the NFL, the Steelers could benefit from his presence in the upcoming season and beyond.

However, signing Araiza comes with its share of risks and scrutiny. The Steelers may face criticism for offering him a second chance in the league, considering the sensitivity of the allegations against him. To mitigate these concerns, a short-term, low-cost contract could be a viable option for both parties, allowing them to reassess the situation as needed.

Ultimately, the Steelers’ potential pursuit of Araiza underscores their willingness to explore opportunities for improvement within their roster. While uncertainties loom, Araiza’s talent and potential could pave the way for a mutually beneficial partnership in the 2024 NFL season.